WATERKnightmare Mermaid
Archetype:
Knightmare
ATK:
1000
LINK-1
View:
7249
Link Arrow:
Bottom
1 "Knightmare" monster, except "Knightmare Mermaid" If this card is Link Summoned: You can discard 1 card; Special Summon 1 "Knightmare" monster from your Deck, then, if this card was co-linked when this effect was activated, you can draw 1 card. You can only use this effect of "Knightmare Mermaid" once per turn. Monsters on the field lose 1000 ATK/DEF, unless they are co-linked.
Knightmare Mermaid — Power Evaluation
Final Score: 56 ± 8 · Confidence: Medium
- Intrinsic: 54 · Deck: 58 · Meta: provisional
- Primary role: Starter / Combo enabler · Secondary: Material body
Why it scores here
Knightmare Mermaid converts a discard into a Special Summon of another Knightmare from the Deck, with a conditional draw when co-linked, so its value is a single extra body with light card-economy support rather than a board-ending engine. Its 400/400 deck presence and 99.5% overlap with Orcust partners confirm it is a reliable piece of the Orcust line, but that is archetype lock-in, not intrinsic strength, and it earns no points from its 1000 ATK or Link-1 cost. The static -1000 ATK/DEF applies to both sides' monsters unless co-linked, which gives only soft interaction. The combo sample is only three boards, all Mitsurugi lines, so the power index of 100 is not treated as proof.
Axis scores
| Axis | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | 60 | Live in 400 of 400 sampled decks as a single copy, but the route depends on Orcust/Knightmare support and combos show no searcher role (observed; inferred for the Deck-to-field route). |
| Combo & Conversion | 55 | Its effect gives one extra Knightmare body from the Deck, and the three recorded boards all carry a power index of 100 with two boss monsters but no starter/material role tags (observed; inferred from the effect text). |
| Resource Economy | 50 | A discard-to-summon is roughly even, and the draw only happens when co-linked, so card advantage depends on the board state (inferred from text; observed netCardAdvantage 6 on Mitsurugi boards, not attributable to this card alone). |
| Effect & Interaction | 45 | The static -1000 ATK/DEF affects all field monsters, including the opponent's, unless they are co-linked, which is soft and symmetric interaction (verified from text). |
| Material Utility | 50 | A WATER Fiend Link-1 with a Bottom arrow is a usable but narrow material body, and it still provides its static effect when blanked by the summon-effect negation only if the static effect is not negated (inferred from text). |
| Resilience & Flexibility | 45 | The once-per-turn summon effect is single-spot and easy to stop, while the static effect is board-wide but not robust to negation (verified from text; inferred for the negation case). |
| Deck-Building Efficiency | 65 | One copy in the Extra Deck with no garnet, lock, or brick restriction, though it is tied to a specific archetype line (verified from deck stats; inferred for slot cost). |
Calculation
Weight profile: 0.7 Starter / Combo enabler + 0.3 Material body. Intrinsic ≈ 54, Deck ≈ 58, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: none. Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck
Strengths
- Reliable Deck-to-field Special Summon of another Knightmare body after a discard
- Board-wide -1000 ATK/DEF on field monsters, which reshapes ATK-based attacks
- Single-copy, no garnet or lock restriction, cheap to run in its archetype
Weaknesses
- Archetype-locked: its value depends on Knightmare and Orcust support
- Discard cost and once-per-turn limit cap the summon route
- Static effect hits both sides' monsters, so it is not a one-sided floodgate
- Thin combo evidence (three boards) with no starter, searcher or material role tags
Counters / choke points
- Lock or hand-trap effects that stop Link Summons or summon effects, as the Mitsurugi guide notes about Droll-type locks
- Graveyard banish and mass-removal lines, as the same guide notes for this deck type
- Negation of the static effect is not covered by the evidence and is treated as a risk rather than a counter
Best use
Starter / Combo enabler (Knightmare body via Deck-to-field summon). Decks: Orcust, Mitsurugi. Suggested copies: 1.
Evidence & gaps
- Verified: Card text: Link Summon trigger, discard 1 to Special Summon a Knightmare from Deck, once per turn, optional draw when co-linked; Static effect: monsters on the field lose 1000 ATK/DEF unless co-linked; Link-1, WATER, Fiend, Bottom arrow, 1000 ATK, single copy in 400 of 400 decks
- Observed: 327 of 400 decks are Orcust (81.8%); Orcust inclusion is 71.4% in the wider StatisticsCard sample; 99.5% co-occurrence with the Orcust partners in top partners; Three recorded boards, all Mitsurugi lines, with power index 100, 0 starter role/material role/payoff role role tags
- Inferred: The Deck-to-field summon acts as a search-like body, not a true searcher; Material value is narrow because of the Bottom arrow and Link-1 cost; Co-link draw is conditional, so resource gain depends on the board state
- Data gaps: Only three recorded combo boards, and none assign this card a role tag No rulings for the static effect in combination with negation or co-link timing No guide in the sample names this card directly (no co_card_ids match 3679218) No dated metagame sample, so meta power is null Deck sample is dominated by a single archetype (Orcust), so cross-archetype portability is unproven






